In a major legal twist that’s already shaking political ground, a federal appeals court has ruled in favor of former President Donald Trump, allowing him to maintain control over National Guard troops deployed in Los Angeles—despite strong pushback from California Governor Gavin Newsom. This decision has sparked major debate across the country and raised serious questions about how far federal power can go when it comes to using military forces inside U.S. states.
What’s the Story?
Recently, Trump took control of California’s National Guard units that were deployed in Los Angeles to handle protests and unrest tied to immigration raids. Governor Newsom challenged this move in court, saying it was an abuse of presidential power and that it violated the state’s rights to control its own troops.
But now, a three-judge panel from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that Trump likely acted within the law. The judges said the situation in L.A. had become violent and dangerous, and under federal law, the president may step in to restore order—even if a state governor says no.
What Did the Judges Say?
The panel, which included two Trump-appointed judges, said the president was likely within his legal rights to take control of the National Guard. They pointed out that during the unrest in L.A., protesters had thrown concrete chunks at federal agents and vandalized buildings. In their view, this showed a level of danger that could justify federal intervention.
This ruling overturned a lower court decision by Judge Charles Breyer, who had previously blocked Trump’s move. Judge Breyer had said Trump didn’t prove there was a “rebellion or invasion,” which is typically needed for the president to bypass state authority.
Why This Decision Matters
-
Historic Precedent: This is the first time since 1965 that a president has taken over state National Guard troops without the governor’s approval.
-
Power Struggle: It marks a major legal and political power struggle between the White House and state governments.
-
Ongoing Legal Battle: Governor Newsom has promised to keep fighting and may appeal to a larger panel or even the Supreme Court.
Reactions Are Pouring In
Donald Trump celebrated the decision as a “HUGE WIN” on his platform Truth Social. He said protecting the country must come before politics.
Meanwhile, Governor Newsom blasted the ruling, calling it “dangerous” and “a step toward authoritarianism.” He argued that states must be able to control their own troops unless there’s a true national emergency.
Civil rights groups are also weighing in. Activists say Trump’s move sets a scary precedent for future leaders to use military force even during peaceful protests.
What Happens Next?
-
The case will return to the lower court for more hearings.
-
Governor Newsom is likely to appeal again.
-
The legal fight could reach the U.S. Supreme Court, especially if more unrest or military action happens.
For now, Trump stays in charge of the National Guard in L.A.—but the fight over who holds ultimate power is far from over.